$$$ and Charter rights of Albertans forfeited by legislators who refuse to do their job?

rally2016 (29 of 42)

The day has finally come – Education Minister David Eggen has officially issued a ministerial order to enforce Gay-Straight Alliances (GSAs) at “defiant” Christian schools.

As stated in an Edmonton Journal article:

“An outside adviser has urged the education minister to close a “significant gap” in law that sets different expectations for public and private schools’ accommodation of LGBTQ students and staff.

Education Minister David Eggen issued a ministerial order Thursday based on the adviser’s report, telling two defiant Edmonton-area Christian private schools they must allow students to create a gay-straight alliance if they request one.

Eggen received the report from lawyer Dan Scott in November 2016 — it was released publicly Thursday.

Scott said private schools are exempt from a law that requires schools to provide a “welcoming, caring, respectful and safe learning environment” for students. He recommended the minister amend the School Act to change that inequity.

“I’m assessing it very carefully,” Eggen said Thursday. “I want to make sure that we are both applying the law in an equitable way, and that people will … understand the importance of having this right afforded to all students regardless of where they go to school.”

The order should also send a message to all schools that the government will “pursue the letter of the law” in how they treat LGBTQ students, Eggen said.

Scott recommended the minister order the schools to submit an updated policy spelling out students’ rights to form a gay-straight alliance, or appoint a trustee to oversee that task if the society refuses. If the society still resists, he should revoke the schools’ accreditation — but only after the end of the school year, Scott said.”

Constitutional Challenge?

I encourage you to read the report published by lawyer Dan Scott for yourself.

Worthy of attention – and not mentioned by any of the media articles so far – is a footnote on page 23 with the following caution for the Education Minister:

“if the Minister intends to revoke accreditation based on non-compliance with section 16.1, and if that non-compliance is based on honestly held religious beliefs, then the Minister will need to assess the impact any decision to cancel accreditation will have on the rights of the Society and the students under section 2(a) of the Charter, balanced against the broader objectives of the Act and the rights of any LGBTQ students who may be attending the schools. The issue of accreditation for private schools, and any rights engaged under section 2(a) of the Charter, are outside the scope of this inquiry, but I raise this as a question / issue for the Minister to consider.”

While this footnote is easy to miss, it is impossible to ignore.

On numerous occasions I have referenced the expert informative analysis prepared by a constitutional lawyer 2 years ago – only one month after Bill 10 was passed into law.

That report urged elected representatives to “review and amend Bill 10 to bring it into compliance with the Charter” with a warning that:

“costly, lengthy and unnecessary litigation could be required to enforce the constitutional rights which protect Alberta’s religious schools, and the right of parents who choose to have their children attend these institutions.”

Legislators refusing to do their job?

For two years MLAs of every political stripe have known that amendments are necessary to ensure this legislation is in full compliance with the Charter – and they have done nothing.

I have personally spoken to MLAs who know the legislation passed through Bill 10 is likely unconstitutional, but they just shrug their shoulders and insist that the courts are the only way to deal with this poorly written legislation.

But that is a lie.

The truth is that there are two ways to change poorly-written legislation:

1. The court system
2. Members of the Legislative Assembly (MLAs)

Strong democracies elect representatives to their Legislature who are supposed to write and amend legislation to best reflect and balance the needs of the people. It is the job we pay them to do.

However, when we allow elected representatives to abdicate their role and forfeit their responsibilities into the hands of a few unelected individuals within the court system then we undermine the very foundations of our democratic system.

And we end up spending a lot more money.

We need legislators who will actually do the job they are already paid to do – to amend poorly written legislation to properly uphold the rights and freedoms guaranteed for all of us under the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms.

Imagine: What if MLAs actually did their job and listened to the expert guidance of constitutional lawyers who told them two years ago to make amendments to section 16.1 of the School Act and then we could avoid a potential court challenge altogether?

The result would be more cost-effective and would achieve freedom and justice in the area of education for everyone.

Ironically, regardless of which advice the Minister of Education chooses to listen to, amendments to the School Act seem to be in order. This means our legislators may soon be faced with a choice of which amendments they will support:

1. Amend section 16.1 of the School Act, based on the advice of a constitutional expert two years ago, saving both time and money on a potential constitutional battle

– OR –

2. Amend section 45.1 of the School Act, based on the advice of the report released publicly yesterday, which will do nothing to avert a looming constitutional court case and only further undermine the freedom of many independent schools to hold to their foundational raison d’etre

Who moves legislators? YOU DO

I’ve said it before: Politicians are not leaders as much as they are followers.

If we actually care about our taxpayer money being used effectively and efficiently and if we care about upholding the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms for all Albertans then we will take action.

Invest some time to read the reports I have linked to in this article.

Contact your elected representatives to make them aware of these reports and your concerns about unnecessary time and taxpayer funds being directed to a potential court challenge in the near future:

1. Send an email (always cc Leela Aheer, Education Critic for Wildrose: chestermere.rockyview@assembly.ab.ca)
2. Post your concerns on their Facebook pages and in the comments section
3. Get on the phone with them
4. Invest some time for an in-person meeting.
5. Attend forums and information sessions hosted by politicians, including registering for telephone town-halls and other events where you can ask specific questions about these educational issues

Understand the profound risks to our democracy and to our pocketbooks when legislators and the electorate become too willing to defer decisions to the courts instead of becoming properly informed and engaged in the legislative process.

Also understand that the erosion of freedom for some has an inevitable impact on us all. Consider a quote by John Carpay, president of the Justice Centre for Constitutional Freedoms:

“Freedom is a seamless garment.  You cannot unravel only one thread of this garment and expect it to remain intact.  A violation of one person’s fundamental freedoms threatens everyone’s freedom.  The respect – or lack of respect – that a government has for parents’ rights in education impacts every child and every family.”

If there is one lesson I have learned over the thousands of hours I have invested in this issue it is that both our democracy and our freedoms are fragile and require effort to maintain and courage to defend.

I urge you to continue to advocate for a thoughtful and balanced legislative approach, which upholds the Charter and balances the constitutional rights and freedoms of everyone – a result that is well worth our efforts.


  1. Chris

    Thank you for writing this article. I am trying to pass along some common sense to this government, but they would rather continue to be blind and ignorantly make devastating decisions that are contrary to public opinion. I will show this article to everybody I know.


  2. Wayne Hansen

    I 100% agree with you. How ever, do you really think that both Conservative leaning parties, Wild Rose and PC are going to choose to publicly say or do anything at a time when they are at the verge of discussing uniting the two parties? If they unite or not, they will not put themselves in a position where people will not vote for either party if they appear to be too Socially Conservative. This LGBTQ agenda has been left alone to get this out of control by the Alt-Left, on what they call Progressive but which is really socially Regressive. The so called free Western society is going to destroy itself and we have let the Alt-Leftist Liberals, the so called New Socialists, which really is just a new name for Communist/Nazi Socialism(both are extreme left), which everyone spoke against in the not to distant past, have taken away our freedoms one by one and will continue to do so if the quiet, gentle, soft spoken, don’t want to get involved, people in this Province and this Country don’t get off their butts and start speaking out. Conservative people need to get Politically involved, become Political Activists and start writing and phoning their MLA’s and MP’s daily/weekly. By writing I also don’t mean sending an email. They won’t even read those. However if you write them a physical letter addressed to them, they have to open then and read them and they bear the biggest impact that you can have. Hold them accountable. Government members have always forgotten who the Employer is and who the Employees are. We, the People are the Employer, they are the Employees. They work for us. If they don’t do the job we ask them to do, we need to insist on their resignation or we Fire them by protesting daily in from of the Government houses until they do.


  3. Colleen

    Moral decay is one of the causes that will sink a nation….instead of teaching the 3R’s, we push LBGTQ and how to give Blow Jobs from K to 12…we have lost our way….Canada the beacon of light is now falling into the septic tank. Why don’t we put the importance of education on the 3R’s. Little kids need to be children, they need to keep their innocence….their minds need to be protected from stuff like this. This is nothing more than raping the mind of a child.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s